It is widely held that benthic foraminifera exhibit species-specific calcification depth preferences,with their tests recording sediment pore water chemistry at that depth (i.e. stable isotope and trace metalcompositions). This assumed depth-habitat-specific pore water chemistry relationship has been used to reconstructvarious palaeoenvironmental parameters, such as bottom water oxygenation. However, many deepwaterforaminiferal studies show wide intra-species variation in sediment living depth but relatively narrowintra-species variation in stable isotope composition. To investigate this depth-habitat–stable-isotope relationshipon the shelf, we analysed depth distribution and stable isotopes of “living” (Rose Bengal stained) benthicforaminifera from two box cores collected on the South Georgia shelf (ranging from 250 to 300m water depth).We provide a comprehensive taxonomic analysis of the benthic fauna, comprising 79 taxonomic groupings.The fauna shows close affinities with shelf assemblages from around Antarctica. We find “live” specimens of anumber of calcareous species from a range of depths in the sediment column. Stable isotope ratios (�13C and�18O) were measured on stained specimens of three species, Astrononion echolsi, Cassidulinoides porrectus,and Buccella sp. 1, at 1 cm depth intervals within the downcore sediment sequences. In agreement with studiesin deep-water settings, we find no significant intra-species variability in either �13Cforam or �18Oforam with sedimentliving depth on the South Georgia shelf. Our findings add to the growing evidence that infaunal benthicforaminiferal species calcify at a fixed depth. Given the wide range of depths at which we find “living”, “infaunal”species, we speculate that they may actually calcify predominantly at the sediment–seawater interface,where carbonate ion concentration and organic carbon availability is at a maximum.